Do you dream of waking up by a mirror-calm lake, falling asleep to the sound of wind in the trees or being able to stop for the night when you find that perfect spot along the road? With a rooftop tent, it's easier to turn the dream of freer adventures into reality.
But when you start looking for your first rooftop tent, you'll soon discover there are two main types: hard-shell tents and soft-shell tents. Both have their advantages, and which suits you best mainly depends on how you plan to use it.
In this guide we go through the differences between hard-shell and soft-shell tents, what to think about before buying and which type suits different ways of camping.
What's the difference between hard-shell and soft-shell tents?
The biggest difference lies in the tent's construction and how it's opened and packed away.
A hard-shell tent has an outer shell made of a rigid material that protects the tent fabric when the tent is closed. Depending on the model, the tent opens with gas struts, hinges or a folding construction.
A soft-shell tent instead has a softer fabric construction and usually a protective cover that zips around the tent while driving. When the tent opens, the sleeping area folds out from the car roof, which often gives a larger sleeping area than the tent's folded size.
There's no universal winner. Hard-shell tents often prioritise quick handling and a compact format, while soft-shell tents often offer a large sleeping area and plenty of ways to customise your camp.
Hard-shell tents – easy, robust and ready for the next adventure
Hard-shell tents have become a popular option for anyone who wants to make camping life as simple as possible. The design lets the tent open quickly when you arrive and close when it's time to move on.
Advantages of hard-shell tents
1. Quick to open and close
One of the biggest advantages of a hard-shell tent is how quickly your bed is ready. Many models can be opened in about a minute, although the time varies between designs.
That's especially appreciated if you're travelling around and changing campsites often. You can stop for the night, get the bed ready and spend your time cooking on the camp stove, exploring the surroundings or just enjoying the peace instead.
2. Protective shell while driving
When the tent is closed, the fabric is protected inside the hard shell. That means many models don't need a traditional soft protective cover.
The shell protects against dirt, road spray and external wear, among other things. How well the tent stands up to weather and moisture, however, also depends on its construction, seals and materials.
3. Often a low profile on the car
Many hard-shell tents have a low and relatively aerodynamic shape when closed. That can be an advantage if you want to keep the car's height down and reduce wind resistance.
It is, however, important to compare the actual dimensions between models. Not all hard-shell tents are low, and a compact soft-shell tent can in some cases be a better option for your particular car.
4. Easy for spontaneous overnight stops
Hard-shell tents are especially well suited if you like letting the trip take unexpected turns. You might find a lovely spot along a forest road, stop by a lake after a day's fishing or decide to extend the weekend trip by another night.
When the tent is quick to handle, it's easier to use it for shorter trips too. You don't need to plan every overnight stay in detail to enjoy your gear.
5. Robust construction
The hard shell gives stable outer protection when the tent is closed. It can also contribute to a durable and practical overall solution.
Bear in mind, though, that weather resistance, insulation and lifespan are also affected by the tent fabric, seams, ventilation and how the tent is cared for.
Are there any downsides to hard-shell tents?
Yes, there are a few things to weigh up.
- The price can be higher. Hard-shell tents often cost more than simpler soft-shell tents, although there are big variations.
- The sleeping area can be more limited. Many models have a sleeping area matching the tent's footprint on the roof, although there are exceptions.
- Weight varies. Some hard-shell tents are relatively heavy, which makes it extra important to check the car's permitted roof load.
- Accessories may need to be model-specific. Annexes and awnings, for example, must be compatible with the tent's design.
If you prioritise easy handling and often move between places, the advantages may still outweigh the downsides.

Soft-shell tents – more sleeping space and greater flexibility
Soft-shell tents are a classic rooftop tent option and suit many different kinds of camping. The design makes it possible to fold out a larger sleeping area from the car roof, which can be especially appreciated by couples and families.
Advantages of soft-shell tents
1. Often a larger sleeping area
One of the main reasons to choose a soft-shell tent is the generous sleeping area. Because the tent folds out beyond the car, the sleeping space can be much larger than the folded size suggests. Above all, you get a full 240 cm of length, so there's room even if you're tall.
That can be a big advantage if you're two adults who want extra room, if the children come along on the adventure or if you simply like being able to stretch out properly.
2. Better storage when the tent is closed
You can easily keep your sleeping bag and pillows in the tent when you close it.
3. Often good value
Soft-shell tents can be a good choice if you want to get started with a rooftop tent without spending your whole budget on the tent itself, or if you're limited by weight – you get more sleeping area per kilo with a soft-shell tent.
The money left over can go on an awning, better sleeping gear or other camping equipment that makes your trips even more comfortable.
4. Suits both short and long trips
Even though soft-shell tents are often favoured by people who stay longer in one place, they're of course just as good for road trips and spontaneous overnight stops.
The difference is that opening it often involves a few more steps, such as opening the protective cover and folding out the sleeping section.
Are there any downsides to soft-shell tents?
Here too there are a few things to consider.
- Opening can take longer. It may involve more steps than a hard-shell tent.
- The protective cover has to be dealt with. When you pack the tent away, the cover has to be zipped around it again. The taller the vehicle you mount the tent on, the harder that gets.
- The folded size can be bigger. Soft-shell tents are taller or have a wider packed shape.
If you want plenty of sleeping space and flexibility, a soft-shell tent can still be an excellent choice.
Which rooftop tent suits your car?
When choosing a rooftop tent, it's easy to get stuck on how it looks or how many people it sleeps. But it's at least as important to think about how the tent suits your car.
Do you have a smaller car or a shorter roof?
Then a compact hard-shell tent like Lagunen Lillen can be an interesting option. But as a rule, soft-shell tents suit smaller cars better, since you get more sleeping area per kilo.
Do you have a pickup?
Pickups are popular with rooftop tent owners because they can offer lots of mounting options. The tent can be placed on a roof platform or another suitable structure, for example, depending on the vehicle model.
Both hard-shell and soft-shell tents can work well here. Think about whether you want to keep the load bed free and how high the tent will be mounted – the higher the mounting, the more you gain from a hard-shell tent.
Do you want both a rooftop tent and other gear?
If you want to combine the tent with bikes, an awning or other equipment, the dimensions become extra important. A compact tent can give more flexibility, but only if the mounting and the total load work for the car.
Always check the car's permitted dynamic roof load, the capacity of the roof rack or roof platform and the tent's mounting requirements. It's the permitted load for the entire mounting solution that must be respected.
Ventilation and condensation: Moisture forms naturally when we breathe and sleep in a tent. Good ventilation and our anti-condensation mat, which is included with all our tents, help deal with the moisture.
Wind and rain: A hard shell protects the tent fabric while driving, but once the tent is open it's the whole construction that decides how well it copes with wind and weather.
Cold: For winter camping, insulation, sleeping bag, mattress and ventilation matter a lot. Neither hard shell nor soft shell is automatically best in the cold, but a soft-shell tent's zip can become a problem if it freezes.
Sleeping comfort: Mattress thickness, the size of the sleeping area and how many people will sleep in the tent often matter more for a good night's sleep than the type of shell.
Our advice is to compare the specifications carefully and choose for the conditions you'll actually use the tent in.
How much does a hard-shell tent cost compared with a soft-shell tent?
Prices vary with size, materials, construction and accessories. Generally, soft-shell tents are better value, while our hard-shell tents are priced somewhat higher.
A slightly more expensive tent that suits your needs better can bring more enjoyment in the long run than a cheaper option that doesn't quite work for how you want to camp.
Choosing the right rooftop tent – five questions to ask yourself
Before you decide, it's worth thinking about the following:
- How many people will sleep in the tent? Start from the number of people and how much space you want.
- How often do you change campsite? If you move every day, quick set-up can be especially valuable.
- What car do you have? Check the roof load, mounting options and available space.
- What gear do you want to add? Awnings, annexes and other loads affect how you should plan the mounting.
- What's your budget? Include any accessories and mounting solutions, not just the tent itself.
Once you've answered those questions, it's often much easier to find the right model.
Our advice – choose a tent for how you want to experience nature
There's no reason to choose a hard-shell tent just because they're popular, or a soft-shell tent just because it can offer lots of sleeping space.
If you love travelling spontaneously, moving on when you feel like it and keeping your packing as light as possible, a hard-shell tent might be the right choice.
If you instead prioritise a large sleeping area, want plenty of room for the family or like to set up a more complete camp, a soft-shell tent might be a better option.
And remember: the best rooftop tent is the one that gets you outside more often.
It might be a night by a lake, a weekend in the forest or a longer trip where you wake up somewhere new every morning. With the right gear, it's easier to make nature part of everyday life.
At Harva Outdoors, we want to inspire more people to discover the freedom of rooftop tents and outdoor life. Take your time comparing the options, think about how you want to travel and choose a solution that suits both you and your car.
See you out there!
Frequently asked questions about hard-shell and soft-shell tents
Are hard-shell tents better than soft-shell tents?
Not in general. Hard-shell tents are often quicker to open and have a protective shell while driving. Soft-shell tents often offer a larger sleeping area and more ways to extend your camp. The best choice depends on your needs.
Which rooftop tent is easiest to open?
Many hard-shell tents are very quick to open and close. Soft-shell tents often involve a few more steps, but it varies between models.
Which rooftop tent is best for a smaller car?
It depends on the car's roof area, permitted roof load and mounting options. A compact hard-shell tent can be a good option, but there are also smaller soft-shell tents.
Can you use a rooftop tent in winter?
Yes, both hard-shell and soft-shell tents can be used in winter if they're suited to the conditions. Make sure you have the right sleeping gear, good ventilation and suitable protection against cold and weather.
Are hard-shell tents more wind-resistant?
Not automatically. The hard shell protects the tent when it's closed, but stability in wind when the tent is open depends on the construction, the choice of materials and how the tent is mounted and anchored.
Do you need a special roof platform for a rooftop tent?
Not always. The tent can be mounted on compatible roof racks or a roof platform, depending on the tent's mounting requirements and the vehicle. Always check the manufacturer's recommendations and the permitted load.
